According
to the World Bank, about half of all people in the developing world (1.94
billion people) lived on less than $1.25 per day in 1981; that fell to 21% by 2010. During this same time period, the population of the developing
world increased by 59%. However, 1.2 billion people are still living in extreme
poverty, 50% of them in fragile states. Those living on less than $2/daydeclined from 2.59 billion in 1981 to 2.4 billion in 2010, while the
world population has increased from 4.5 billion to over 6.7 billion over that
period. According to UNDP's Multidimensional Poverty Index, about 1.7 billion people - a third of the population of the 109
countries covered by the index - live in multidimensional poverty. Meantime, ILO reports that the number of working poor is declining globally; from the
early 2000's to 2013, the number of workers living below $1.25/day declined
from more than 600 million to 375 million (11.9% of total employment), while
the number of the workers living below $2/day declined from more than 1.1
billion to 839 million (26.7% of total employment) over the same period. Now,
that serious poverty reduction has proven possible, world attention is
beginning to focus on income disparities.
World GDP
passed $83 trillion (PPP), growing at an estimated 2.1% in
2013, considerably slower than the 4.6% IMF
average forecast for 2011-2015. Emerging market and developing economies' growth averaged 5%, while advanced economies grew at 1.4%. Although G20's share
of the world's economy decreased from 87% in 2011 to 77% in 2012, the U.S., the
eurozone, and Japan continue to account for almost half of global output. UNDP forecasts
that by 2020 the combined GDP of Brazil, China and India will exceed the
combined output of Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Great Britain and the U.S.
Average GDP per capita in emerging market economies is expected to grow from
$7,285 in 2013 to about $10,000 in 2018, while in advanced economies, it is
projected to grow from $41,250 to $50,420 over the same period. The UN is expecting world
GDP to grow at 3% in 2014, and 3.3% in 2015, although key risks and
uncertainties remain.
The World
Economic Forum identifies income disparity as the most likely global risk over the next decade,
while the impacts of unemployment and underemployment are seen as being both
likely and serious. UNDP indicates that over the past 20 years, within-country income inequality increased
by 9% in the developed countries and 11% in developing countries. About 75% of
the households of developing countries are living in societies with higher
income inequality today than in the 1990s. It notes that continuing current
inequality trends versus the ‘best-ever' inequality rate of each country could
mean an extra 1 billion people living below the $2 per day poverty line in 2030.
Oxfam International also warns about rising wealth concentration and unequal opportunities, as the richest
1% of the population owns about 46% of global wealth, $110 trillion, while the
bottom 50% of the population barely owns $1.7 trillion (some 0.7% of the
world's wealth), about the same as the world's 85 richest people. Credit Suisse
notes that in 2013, global wealth has reached $241
trillion, or some $51,600 per adult; however, 86%
of it is owned by the top 10% of the world population. The ratio between wages
and profit is increasingly and dangerously imbalanced. Well aware of this, financial leaders are placing inequality and structural reforms on the top of the world
policy agenda. Meanwhile, movements like the 1% versus 99% along with other
protests and strikes around the world question the integrity of financial
leaders and the fairness of the current economic system calling for changes
toward more sustainable prosperity. New indicators that look beyond GDP are
being developed (e.g. see the State of the Future Index) for measuring progress and prosperity, and to help policymakers use
new technologies and financial tools for reshaping economies and enhancing
public welfare.
Over 2
billion people connected to the Internet provides a new kind of market for
self-employment and SMEs to find markets rather than applying for jobs. New
technologies and innovations are empowering people around the world, creating
new forms of business with the potential to raise living standards and reduce
income disparities. The Post-2015 development agenda envisions increased
partnerships among all actors, mainly with the private sector, emphasizing the
role and accountability of large corporations concerning their social and
environmental impact.
The
landscape of geoeconomic power is changing rapidly as the influence of emerging
economies and of multinational enterprises is rising. New geopolitical economic
alliances are growing: the G20 is already G35+, the Group of 77 now includes
more than 130 countries encompassing over 60% of the world's population, and
over 110 countries are involved in some 22 regional and other trade agreement
negotiations. As regional trade agreements interlock, world trade and
multilateral processes will increase.
Trade has
been a powerful driving force for economic development over the past 30 years,
increasing productivity and living standards in many developing countries,
mainly through outsourcing of manufacturing and service jobs to low-wage
high-tech economies. The newly emerging-market middle class continues the
development process through increasing local demand, while also moving
lower-value jobs to other developing economies, thus spreading the prospects
for global prosperity. WTO notesthat, in 2012, exports from developing countries increased 4%, while
those from developed countries declined 3%. OECD estimates that world
trade growth will continue, increasing from the
estimated 3% in 2013 to 4.8% in 2014, and 5.9% in 2015. However, tax systems
and financial regulations have not kept up with the complex growth of financial
instruments requiring adjustments to ensure fairness.
For the
first time, FDI flows to developing countries overtook those to developed
countries, representing 52% of global FDI inflows in 2012. Global FDI inflows fell by 18% in 2012, to US$1.35 trillion, with developed
economies' FDI inflows declining by 32%. FDI outflows from developing economies
also grew, reaching $426 billion, a record 31% of the world total, while that
of developed countries dropped by 23%, to $909 billion. Flows from the BRICS
countries rose from $7 billion in 2000 to $145 billion in 2012 (almost 10% of
the world total.) China became the world's third top investor, after the U.S.
and Japan. The number of State-owned TNCs increased from 650 in 2010 to 845 in
2012, their FDI flows reaching about $145 billion, about 11% of the world
total. For 2013, UNCTAD forecasts FDI to remain close to the 2012 level-at a
max $1.45 trillion, with potential growth to $1.6 trillion in 2014 and $1.8
trillion in 2015.
By 2030,
the global middle class is expected to grow by 66% - about 3 billion more
consumers with increased purchasing power and expectations. Yet, the economic
slowdown and the prolonged "jobless recovery" lowering demand, might
continue to affect unemployment. The ILO estimates that in 2013, there were some 202 million people unemployed
worldwide, 5 million more than in 2012, and if current trends continue, global
unemployment might reach over 215 million by 2018. An estimated 23 million
people have dropped out of the labor market due to rising long-term
unemployment and discouragement. The most affected are the young people - aged
15-24, whose unemployment rate has reached 13.1%, some 74.5 million in 2013 and
although some 40 million net new jobs are expected to be created yearly over
the next five years, this does not meet the needs of an estimated 42.6 million
people expected to enter the labor market every year. OECD estimates that unemployment will remain close to 8% by the end of 2014,
meaning that about 48 million people will be out of work in the 34 OECD
countries. The rates will vary from under 5% in Germany, to close to 28% in
Spain and Greece, with young people continuing to be the most affected, with
rates about 60% in Greece, and around 52% in South Africa. Meantime, many
businesses lack qualified workers; hence, a better collaboration is needed
among the private sector, civil society, government agencies, and education
institutions to create the human capital with the qualifications needed by
today's and tomorrow's job markets. Estimates show that spending 1.2% of GDP on active labor market policies could
create an additional 3.9 million jobs in the developed economies and the EU
region, notes ILO.
Almost 48% of all employment in 2013 is "vulnerable employment" with most
of those people having limited or no access to social security or secure
income. the informal economy remains widespread in the developing world with
most unable to exercise their basic legal and social rights. Such informal
economy rates in Latin America vary from below 50% in some countries, to 70% or more
in low-income Andean and Central American countries, while in some countries of
South and South-East Asia the rates could reach up to 90% of total employment.
Meantime, about 30 million people are slaves today, the majority of which are in Asia.
Agriculture
is the second-largest source of employment in the world, with 35% of the
workforce (over 1 billion people worldwide). Its contribution to global GDP is
only 6%, compared with 31% for industry and 63% for the service sector. The Bali
Packageadopted by the WTO in December 2013 is
expected to address the "tariff quota", land-use programs, export subsidies,
and other measures that will improve developing countries' access to world
markets, while also addressing their food security.
Official
development assistance (ODA) by the 26 DAC countries in 2012 totaled $128.4 billion
(preliminary data, 2011 dollars), a 4% decline from 2011's $133.7 billion, and
a 6% decline from 2010, when global ODA peaked at $136.7 billion. Meanwhile,
South-South cooperation increased to 10-15% of total official aid, although in
real terms it is estimated to be much higher, as the valuation of their
services tends to be lower than that of western contractors. Global remittance
flows in 2012 reached $528 billion, out of which $401 billion were to
developing countries. The World
Bank estimates global remittances to reach $550 billion
in 2013 and $594 billion by 2014, with $414 and $449 billion respectively to
developing countries. Crowdfunding via cell phones, apps and websites is
increasing; Devex estimates that about $2 billion has already been crowdfunded for
development.
Although
the 2012 State of the Microcredit reports that the number of very poor
families receiving a microloan rose from 7.6 million in 1997 to 137.5 million
in 2010, affecting more than 687 million people, the 2013 report found that 13 million fewer of the poorest families received microloans
in 2011 compared to 2010. This is the fist decline since global records were
kept in 1998. Nevertheless, 124 million families in extreme poverty received
microloans; assuming five people per family, 621 million people were affected
in 2011.
The UN
estimates that a tax on international financial transactions might generate up
to $250 billion per year, which could help offset the costs of the continuing
economic, financial, fuel, climate, and food crises. Taxes on shadow banking
could be a new source to help address development gaps. The overall assets in
the global shadow banking system have seen a rapid increase, rising from €20
trillion (~ $27.3 trillion) in 2002 to €52.5 trillion (~ $71.7 trillion) in
2011. The U.S. and the eurozone have the world's largest shadow banking
systems, in 2011, with assets worth some €18 trillion (~ $24.6 trillion) and
€17.2 trillion (~ $23.5 trillion), respectively.
The world
needs a long-term strategic plan for a global partnership between rich and
poor. Such a plan should use the strength of free markets and rules based on
global ethics. It should encourage increased roles for business in addition to
philanthropic initiatives like Bill Gates' challenge to billionaires to share
half their wealth. Since half of the world's major economies are
multinationals, these businesses play a crucial role in poverty alleviation and
building a sustainable economic system. Approximately 1 billion people in 96
countries now belong to a cooperative, according to the International
Co-operative Alliance. Over 8,000 companies and 4,000 civil society
organizations from 145 countries participate in the UN Global Compact,
combining business interests with global priorities to help poverty
alleviation, climate change mitigation, and women's empowerment, while protecting
children's and labor rights, and fighting corruption. Such Conventional
approaches to poverty reduction (technical assistance and credit) that work in
low- and middle-income stable countries do not work in fragile countries, which
need stability first. Richer countries used to send money, talent, and
equipment to help poorer countries with mixed results; pay-for-performance is
now being explored. For example, Norway will pay Brazil up to $1 billion by
2015 for deforestation reduction targets; it is also working similar deals with
Indonesia, Guyana, and Tanzania.
Ethical
market economies require improved fair trade, increased economic freedom, a
"level playing field" guaranteed by an honest judicial system with
adherence to the rule of law and by governments that provide political
stability, a chance to participate in local development decisions, reduced
corruption, insured property rights, business incentives to comply with social
and environmental goals, a healthy investment climate, and access to land,
capital, and information. Direction from central government with relatively
free markets is competing with the decentralized, individualized private
enterprise for lifting people out of poverty.
Challenge 7
will be addressed seriously when market economy abuses and corruption by
companies and governments are intensively prosecuted and when the inequality
gap - by all definitions - declines in 8 out of 10 consecutive years.
Regional Considerations
Africa: Although
the AfDB notes that 313 million people (34% of the region's population) are now
middle-class, half of the current middle class is significantly dependent on
African diaspora that sends more money back home ($31 billion) than Africa
receives from foreign aid. Since the late 1990s, much of Africa has experienced
4-6% economic growth. In 2013, its economic growth was 4% and the AfDB projects 4.8% and 5 to 6% for 2014 and 2015 respectively, noting that the
economic growth is more broad-based, driven by increased continental trade and
domestic demand, and infrastructure development. Sub-Saharan Africa is the world's
second-fastest growing region, with half of today's 30 fastest-growing economies. If these trends continue, there could be one
billion people in the middle class by 2060. Yet, current per capita income
levels remain low due to population growth and high income disparities-100,000
people hold 80% of the wealth, according to AfDB. For the first time since
1981, less than half (48%) of Sub-Saharan Africa's population is living below
$1.25/day; the number of the region's extremely poor doubled over this period,
from 205 million to 414
million, representing about 35% of the world's
extreme poor. The WB optimistic forecast is that extreme poverty rate will fall to between 16% and 30% by 2030.
Also, the average income of the extremely poor remains at approximately half of
the $1.25/day threshold, with the region having the countries with the highest
rates of intensity of deprivation of population living in multidimensional
poverty and the countries with the highest
inequality in the world-South Africa, Comoros, and Namibia.
Since one
in every three births will be African by 2050, and almost one in three children
under the age of 18 will also be African, unless jobs creation and new forms of
cyber self-employment increases considerably, poverty and social instability
could be rampant. Dependency on commodities with fluctuating prices, lack of
infrastructure, and rampant corruption make economic growth and development
challenging. FDI to Africa rose from $15 billion in 2002 to $50 billion in 2012 (with a peak of $59 billion in 2008), while outflows grew from $5
billion in 2011 to $14 billion in 2012. BRIC accounted for 36% of the region's exports in 2012, at $144 billion, close to $148 billion that were its exports to
the EU and the U.S. combined. Intra-African trade continues to account for only
10% of exports on the continent and is too weak to be an incentive for changing
trade patterns. This might change with the Continental Free Trade Area expected
to be set in 2017. Remittances to sub-Saharan African are estimated at $31 billion in 2012. Approximately 56.2 million hectares (5% of Africa's
agricultural land) is subject to land-grabbing, further threatening the
livelihoods of the already poor. There is an increase in the promotion of small
and micro enterprises through policies and funds, but township and local innovation
systems are also needed to help reduce the rich-poor gap. Urban farming in the
Democratic Republic of Congo is converting many unemployed people into small
farmer entrepreneurs. For a steady development, the region should address in a
systemic way its complex challenges: poor governance, corruption, high birth
rates, gender inequality, income and location biases, weak infrastructure, high
indirect costs, armed conflicts, environmental degradation and climate change,
poor health conditions, and lack of education.
Asia and Oceania: The historic speed and volume of Asia's economic growth has begun to
slow, but remains a major factor in the future of civilization. The EIU is expecting the economic growth of China to continue slowing from 9.2% in 2011 to
7.7% in 2013 and to 5.9% in 2018. This may not keep pace with employment needs.
FDI flows to developing Asia fell 7% in 2012, to $407 billion, over 50% of which went to China and India. Japan's long-term
relatively stagnate economy complicated by the Fukushima nuclear disaster, is
beginning to improve over it's 0.5% contraction in 2013. India's government is projecting an increase from 5% in 2013 to 6% in 2014, 7% in 2015, and 8% in 2016.
Increasing geopolitical tensions in the region, plus corruption, organized
crime, pollution, growing rich-poor divides, potentials for increasing
shortages of water, energy, and food make continued poverty reduction
difficult. Natural disasters and the effects of climate change are threatening
the development and the very existence of entire Pacific communities. Thus,
there are speculations that the Asian economy as-a-whole might not surpass a
middle-income level in the foreseeable future. Nevertheless, Asia's middle
class is expected to grow from the current 500 million to 1.75 billion by 2020. China
brought more people out of extreme poverty than any country in history. It
reduced its extreme poverty rate from 84% of population in 1981 to 12.5% today,
although 161.7 million people are still living in multidimensional poverty.
Chinese has more than one million millionaires and adding more than any other
county. The middle class in India has grown to 300 million people. Although it
employs about 2.2 million directly in the IT sector and 8 million indirectly,
over 11 million people are unemployed. India has about a third of the world's
extreme poverty population, with some 612.2 million people living in
multidimensional poverty. Remittances to developing Asia totaled over $218 billion in 2012 and the World Bank
estimates that they could grow to over $255 billion by 2015. The top recipients
in 2012 were India ($71 billion), China ($60 billion), and the Philippines ($26
billion). Meanwhile, China, Japan, and South Korea are negotiating a Free Trade Agreement. This would be one of the biggest free trade
areas, accounting for 70% of Asia's and 20% of the world's GDP, and representing
35% ($5.4 trillion) of world's trade. A larger Asian economic integration with
ASEAN, an Asian Monetary Union, and an Asian Union are also in discussion. The
search for lower labor costs and China starting to outsource manufacturing
continues the intraregional restructuring in Asian. However, increasing
pollution, water and energy problems, and the rich-poor gap threaten the future
economic growth of developing Asia. Israel's strong economic development continues thanks to a favorable entrepreneurship climate and great support to
innovation. In the MENA region, youth
unemployment is about 27% and nearly 5 million people
are added to the workforce annually. The Arab Labor Organization estimates that
a 1% increase of unemployment rate reduces GDP by 2.5%. Economic growth in MENA
is likely to gradually pick up from the estimated 2.6% in 2013, to 5% in 2018, mainly due to Saudi Arabia and other
oil-rich Gulf states. The Arab Spring created momentum for building a more open
economy and democratic society. Remittance inflows to MENA are estimated to be
about $49
billion in 2012, a 14.3% increase
compared to 2011, mainly driven by Egypt, which accounts for over 40% of total
remittance inflows to the region.
Europe: The EU is one of the richest regions in the world with a GDP of over $16,000 billion (PPP), but concerns remain about eurozone countries' debt and direction
of fiscal policy. The European
Commission expects GDP to grow by 1.4% in 2014 and
1.9% in 2015 across the EU (after stagnation in 2013 and 0.4% contraction in
2012), but more slowly in the euro area. Discontent continues among the
population as austerity measures increase inequality. In 2014, unemployment is expected to stay at about 11% across the EU, but above 12% in the
eurozone. By the end of 2013, a total of 19.3 million people were out of work
in the euro zone, with unemployment rates varying from around 27% in Greece and Spain, to about 5% in Austria and
Germany. The divide between the creditor countries in the north and the debtor
nations in the south continues to widen. The eurozone leaders adopted a set of
short- and long-term measures to save the euro and stimulate economic growth
and are discussing several proposals, including a financial transaction tax
across the eurozone, more centralized supervision of banks, and issuance of
eurobonds. The crisis also triggered negotiations over structural reforms,
which might include a tighter political integration with more solidarity and
concessions on fiscal sovereignty. In response to economic and financial
crisis, a new set of rules to enhance EU economic governance entered into force
on 13 December 2011, including stronger preventive and corrective action
through a reinforced Stability and Growth Pact and deeper fiscal coordination;
minimum requirements for national budgetary frameworks; and preventing and
correcting macroeconomic and competitiveness imbalances. The Market in
Financial Instruments II reform is intended to regulate financial markets and commodity prices across
the EU, to prevent market distortions and abuse. As a result of the financial
crises, 72% of the population believes that creating jobs and combating
unemployment should be the bloc's top policy priority. The economic costs
incurred by corruption
in the EU are estimated at €120 billion (~ $163.8
billion) a year (close to the total EU annual budget), and some 40% of the
companies participating in the 2013 Eurobarometer survey consider corruption,
nepotism, and patronage to be an impediment for doing business. This is
expected to be addressed by the comprehensive anti-corruption package adopted
by the EC in 2011. The ODA from the EU-15
DAC members was $63.7 billion in 2012, representing over 50% of the world
ODA. FDI inflows to the EU decreased by 41%, while outflows decreased by 40% in
2012. In the European transition region, growth rate is expected to pick up
from 1.4% in 2013 to almost 3% in 2014, with further growth in 2015-2018.
Although the Stabilization Fund and revenues from oil and gas exports helped
Russia recover from the global financial crisis better than expected, its
economy has continued to weaken, due to internal constraints such as unfavorable business environment mainly to
SMEs, too much bureaucracy, and high inflation that has prevented the central
bank from cutting interest rates to stimulate growth. Economic growth is
expected to recover to 2.9% in 2014. In 2012, FDI from the Russian Federation accounted for 92% of the total $55 billion flows from transition economies.
Latin America: Latin America and the Caribbean remains a highly unequal society, with
the richest 10% receiving about 48% of total income while the poorest 10% captures only
1.8%. Nevertheless, during the 2000s, inequality
declined considerably. In Brazil and Mexico is at
the lowest level since the 1960s when data records started. Some 40% of social
inequality reduction is due to lower wage inequality, increasing skilled
workers, and increased minimum wages, while another 13%-20% is due to more
progressive government transfers. Decreasing inequality also accounts for
33%-50% of the poverty reduction in the region. The share of people living
below $1.25/day dropped from approximately 12% for the last two decades of the
20th century to 6% now, and unemployment decreased from 6.4% in 2011 to 6.2% in 2013 according
to ECLAC. Brazil reduced the number of people living in poverty from 41 million
in 2002 to 15.7 million in 2013; the middle class increased by 42 million
people since 2003, and income per capita grew by 78%; it pledges to continue creating an investment-friendly economic environment and to
use its rich natural resources to improve living standards sustainably. Peru
has reduced its poverty rate from 59% in 2004 to 28% in 2012. The Community of
Latin American and Caribbean States pledged to continue the efforts for poverty eradication and reduction of inequalities by
increasing regional economic, social, and political integration. Regional
economic growth is expected to increase from 2.6% in 2013 to 3.2% in 2014.
According to OECD, less than 4% of state revenue is generated by personal
income taxes, compared with 27% in industrialized countries, while VAT is
placing an additional burden on poor customers. The "shadow economy" is
estimated to be about 40% relative to the formal one. Remittance inflows
reached an estimated $62
billion in 2012, of which Mexico receives 37%.
Although in South America FDI increased 12%, the region's total FDI inflows
decreased 2% in 2012 compared to 2011, to a total $244 billion (about half going to Brazil), due to a decline in Central America and
the Caribbean. Fiscal and economic reforms are improving stability, although
country and regional policies increasingly focused on national interests and
ethical behavior might affect future foreign investments. A World Economic
Forum survey has found that on average, 64% of Latin Americans think that their
country's economic system favors the wealthy, with the rates varying from 86%
in Chile, to 32% in Venezuela. Chile is one of the countries with the highest
rate of social inequality.
North America: The U.S. economic slow but steady recovery makes it still the leading
world economy and is likely to continue to be so mostly due to its
entrepreneurial spirit, university system, and innovative patent portfolio.
Potential trade agreements such as the Transatlantic Trade and
Investment Partnership and the Trans-Pacific Partnership might open new global economic opportunities. Intra-NAFTA (Canada,
Mexico, and USA) trade has tripled in its 20 years of existence, helping
continental economic integration. By the end of 2013, the U.S. unemployment
rate fell to 6.7%, a five-year low, and GDP growth is expected to pick up from about 2% in 2013 to about 3% in 2014. However, a World
Economic Forum survey has found that North Americans see increasing inequality as the most
important challenge facing their region. The rich-poor gap continues to widen;
in 2011 and 2012 the official poverty
rate was 15% (46.5 million people), 2.5% higher than in 2007, before the
recession. From 1978 to 2012, for the 350 top publicly owned firms, the CEOs
average options realized compensation increased about 875%, versus 5.4% growth for a typical worker's
compensation, with the CEO-to-worker compensation ratio reaching 273-to-1 in
2012, and Oxfam notes that since 2009, the wealthiest 1% captured 95% of post-financial
crisis growth, while the bottom 90% became poorer. Increasing profits at the
expense of lower wages is not sustainable and undermines markets at home, as
well as people's confidence in the system. The U.S. continues to provide the
largest amount of ODA, with a total of $29.9 billion in 2012. Canada's economy
is focused on resources, with no clear sustainability strategy. By the end of
2013, unemployment reached 7.2%, but over 15% for the young people, most of
whom finished university with high debts and few jobs matching their
qualifications. Canadianfamilies'
income share of top 20% is 47.2%, while for the bottom
20% is 4.1%. The livelihood of 400+ remote communities in the boreal and Arctic
regions remains problematic and unaddressed. The merger of the Canadian
International Development Agency with the Department of Foreign Affairs,
International Trade and Development indicates a new approach to aid, by also
including commercial and foreign-policy objectives to programs, rather than
exclusively humanitarian ones.
Economic Income Inequality (% income share of the
richest 1%)